Thursday, January 24, 2013

Book Review: Redwall


Ok, ok, so I'm behind the times. Redwall came out in 1986. But I only just got around to reading it a couple of weeks ago. I read it in one sitting in one night.

Interesting book + fast reader = well, I didn't get to bed until after 11, but I finished the book!

I've been skeptical of the Redwall series for years. My younger brothers enjoyed them, but I was grown by the time they discovered them and they were just kids. I had tried getting into another series they liked (Wally McDoogle) but it just wasn't for me. (Admittedly a very different series, but I was too busy to pick up a book I might not enjoy at the time.)

Another turnoff was that I had heard Redwall described as C.S. Lewis's Narnia meets Tolkien meets King Arthur. I don't particularly like it when books are described in terms of other books. In this case, I think it was a case of well intentions gone astray.

They say it's like Narnia because the animals talk and have their own land. Let us all take a moment to realize that Lewis is not the only person to have thought of that.

They say Tolkien because there's a battle between good and evil (at least, that's pretty much the only connection I could come up with).

They say Arthur because ... well, Arthur is quite a legitimate comparison.

But really, I think Redwall stands on it's own. There's no need to compare it to the greats. It's its own land, story, and time. I think children would understand it entirely and enjoy it, but it is not just for children. I rather enjoyed reading it myself. Actually, I enjoyed it so much that I'm going to ask my brothers what books they have from the series laying around that I can borrow from them.

Tales of good versus evil never go out of style. Neither do tales of heroism and bravery. Everyone has a part to play, and though you know how the story will broadly end - the book is worth the journey.

I, for one, look forward to traveling the seasons of Redwall.


This post does contain affiliate links. This means that, at no additional cost to you, I may receive a commission for referring business. Thank you for your support!

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm an adult and I enjoy the Redwall books!

Sophie said...

In the couple weeks since I read the first book, I've read the following four in the series! (I've been borrowing the aforementioned books my brothers have *grin*)